Old Man Warner responded to the news of the North Village considering ending the lottery with disdain, expressing strong disapproval for any suggestion of change.
When Old Man Warner heard that the North Village is considering ending the lottery, his reaction was a mixture of disbelief, anger, and resistance to change. As a staunch believer in the tradition and ritual of the lottery, Warner expressed strong disapproval for any suggestion of altering or abandoning this long-standing practice.
In his outcry against the potential change, Old Man Warner emphasized the significance of the lottery as a communal event that brings the villagers together. He argued that ending the lottery would not only disrupt the social fabric of the community but also lead to dire consequences. Warner firmly believed that the lottery served as a means of purging the village of evil and maintaining order and prosperity. He resented any form of opposition to the lottery, viewing it as a threat to the stability and values of their society.
To further illustrate the importance of tradition and resistance to change, it is worth noting a quote from Mahatma Gandhi: “A nation’s culture resides in the hearts and in the soul of its people.” This quote emphasizes how deeply entrenched traditions become part of a community’s identity, making it difficult for individuals like Old Man Warner to accept any deviation from established customs.
Here are some interesting facts about the concept of the lottery:
-
The origins of the lottery can be traced back thousands of years, with different variations found in ancient civilizations such as China, Greece, and Rome.
-
The modern notion of the lottery, which involves a random selection of winners for prizes or benefits, emerged during the medieval period in Europe.
-
Lotteries have historically been used as a means of raising funds. In the 18th century, European governments utilized lotteries as a financial resource for various public projects, including infrastructure development.
-
The world’s oldest recorded lottery is believed to be the Dutch State Lottery, established in 1726.
-
The concept of a “lottery” extends beyond monetary prizes. For example, some countries and states use lotteries to allocate scarce resources like organ transplants or coveted public school placements.
Now, let’s include a table outlining the pros and cons of ending the lottery:
Pros of Ending the Lottery:
- Elimination of the perceived cruelty and harm associated with the ritualistic sacrifice that the lottery entails.
- Abolishing the fear and anxiety that the lottery perpetuates within the community.
- A shift towards a more egalitarian and fair society, where individuals are not subjected to random acts of violence or discrimination.
Cons of Ending the Lottery:
- Loss of a longstanding tradition that has served as a unifying force within the community.
- Potential disruption of social order and the symbolic significance the lottery holds.
- Neglecting the belief that the lottery ensures prosperity and protection against evil forces in the village.
Overall, Old Man Warner’s reaction to the potential end of the lottery reflects the deep-rooted attachment individuals can have to traditions, even in the face of changing times. It underscores the conflict between preservation and progress, highlighting the tension between the desire for stability and the need for societal evolution.
See the answer to your question in this video
In this YouTube video summary and analysis of Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery,” the notes highlight the opening scenes of the story, the symbolism present throughout, and the exploration of themes such as tradition, ritual, conformity, and the banality of evil. The video explains how the setting of a small village on the morning of the lottery builds tension and introduces the characters. The symbolism of the black box and its shabby appearance represents the outworn tradition of the lottery, while other symbols like stones, households, and the black box itself highlight the town’s loyalty to ancient rituals. The analysis delves into the themes of tradition, ritual, conformity, and the banality of evil, depicting how the story challenges blind adherence to tradition and the consequences it can have. Overall, the video provides a comprehensive understanding of the story’s key elements and themes.
In addition, people ask
Then, What does Old Man Warner say about the lottery? Response to this: Answer and Explanation: In "The Lottery" (1948), Old Man Warner symbolizes tradition and blind faith. He states, "There’s always been a lottery." This shows that the villagers were willing to follow tradition, regardless of the brutality.
Also question is, What is the reaction of Old Man Warner to the fact that in the north village they re talking of giving up the lottery?
“Jones.” “They do say,” Mr. Adams said to Old Man Warner, who stood next to him, “that over in the north village they’re talking of giving up the lottery.” Old Man Warner snorted. “Pack of crazy fools,” he said.
Then, When Old Man Warner hears that some places have dropped the lottery what does he do?
The reply will be: When Old Man Warner hears that some places have dropped the lottery, how does he feel? He says: "giving up the lottery could lead to a return to living in caves, nothing but trouble."
Thereof, How do the townspeople feel about making changes to the lottery what about Old Man Warner? In reply to that: In Jackson’s ‘The Lottery’, the villagers are reluctant to make changes to the generations’ old tradition. This is shown by the aggravation in Old Man Warner’s words when he hears that other villages are considering getting rid of the lottery. He states, ”Pack of crazy fools.
What does old man Warner say about the lottery?
Mr. Adams tells Old Man Warner that people in the north village might stop the lottery, and Old Man Warner ridicules young people. He says that giving up the lottery could lead to a return to living in caves. Mrs. Adams says the lottery has already been given up in other villages, and Old Man Warner says that’s “nothing but trouble.”
What did Mr Adams say to old man Warner?
"They do say," Mr. Adams said to Old Man Warner, who stood next to him, "that over in the north village they’re talking of giving up the lottery. Old Man Warner snorted. "Pack of crazy fools," he said. "Listening to the young folks, nothing’s good enough for them.
What is the setting of the lottery? "The Lottery" is set in an unnamed small town in the USA. The story takes place on June 27th, but no year is given. What is the setting of "The Lottery?" "The Lottery" is set in an unnamed small town in the USA. The story takes place on June 27th, but no year is given. What are the boys doing in the square at the beginning of the story?
Keeping this in consideration, Why did the lottery start?
Response to this: Old Man Warner ‘s comments suggest that the Lottery ritual may have started as a human sacrifice to the gods of the harvest and fertility. He seems to tie the labor of farming and cultivated crops with the better lifestyle the community has enjoyed since they stopped, as he puts it, living in caves.